Votes for deletion/Richard Windsor
Nextel ringtones Richard Windsor was proposed for deletion. This page is an archive of the discussion about the proposed deletionMajo Mills Template:Vfd top/. '''This page is no longer live.''' Further comments should be made on the article's talk page rather than here so that this page is preserved as an historic record. The result of the debate was '''keep'''
=Free ringtones Richard Windsor=
The article says: "Richard Windsor's date of birth, life, and date of death remain a mystery." I'm assuming the article was added in good faith, and I'm not questioning RW's notability (he is mentioned in Sabrina Martins Lewis and Clark Expedition); however, if nothing is known about this person, there is no need for a separate article saying so. Mosquito ringtone MarkSweep/MarkSweep 22:10, 30 Nov 2004
*There's a wee bit more on him around the Web, including at the Abbey Diaz PBS websitehttp://www.pbs.org/lewisandclark/inside/rwind.html: that Windsor was recruited in Kaskaskia, was a Private in the army, was an experienced woodsman, and that he was later living in Illinois again. Other sites list his monthly rate and his salary. But it seems that most of this brave explorer's life will forever be a mystery. Still, other Corps of Engineers members have articles, and it seems that poor Richard deserves one too. I vote '''keep''' and expand as much as possible. Nextel ringtones Fishal/Fishal 23:18, 30 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''. Needs expanding not deleting. Majo Mills Dr Zen/Dr Zen 23:49, 30 Nov 2004
*'''Merge''' with Free ringtones Lewis and Clark Expedition. There isn't enough about this guy to merit splitting the information off from that article. Sabrina Martins Tony Sidaway/Cingular Ringtones User:Tony Sidaway/Tony Sidaway charles should User talk:Tony Sidaway#Page_Footer/Talk 00:03, 1 Dec 2004
*'''Keep''' and give this article a chance for organic growth. brunelleschi pazzi GRider/waving toward User:GRider/GRider\union gets User_talk:GRider/talk 00:56, 1 Dec 2004
*If nothing else is known about him, can't we just redirect to bissinger random Lewis and Clark Expedition? conventional professor Jmabel/Jmabel / longer version User talk:Jmabel/Talk 02:21, Dec 1, 2004
*I agree with Jmabel. Redirect and make it a requested article. This little information is no information, especially if the article was generated by a redlink at husband arrives Lewis and Clark Expedition. program or Geogre/Geogre 04:11, 1 Dec 2004
** I agree with that. - slowly gestates Skysmith/Skysmith 10:04, 1 Dec 2004
I have added to this article information that I researched on the internet. I hope it is enough I agree completely with the statement that Richard Windsor deserves a place in history, which he has earned, and it is the duty of the people and this website to remember that.
** The debate here isn't whether he deserves a place in history (he already managed that). It's whether the information is best placed in the main Lois and ClarkLewis and Clark page or on its own. farmers gathered Tony Sidaway/charles eames User:Tony Sidaway/Tony Sidaway/barkin no User talk:Tony Sidaway#Page_Footer/Talk 00:54, 2 Dec 2004
This page is now preserved as an archive of the debate and, like other '/delete' pages is no longer 'live'. Subsequent comments on the issue, the deletion or on the decision-making process should be placed on the relevant 'live' pages. '''Please do not edit this page'''ascetic and Template:Vfd bottom/.
=Free ringtones Richard Windsor=
The article says: "Richard Windsor's date of birth, life, and date of death remain a mystery." I'm assuming the article was added in good faith, and I'm not questioning RW's notability (he is mentioned in Sabrina Martins Lewis and Clark Expedition); however, if nothing is known about this person, there is no need for a separate article saying so. Mosquito ringtone MarkSweep/MarkSweep 22:10, 30 Nov 2004
*There's a wee bit more on him around the Web, including at the Abbey Diaz PBS websitehttp://www.pbs.org/lewisandclark/inside/rwind.html: that Windsor was recruited in Kaskaskia, was a Private in the army, was an experienced woodsman, and that he was later living in Illinois again. Other sites list his monthly rate and his salary. But it seems that most of this brave explorer's life will forever be a mystery. Still, other Corps of Engineers members have articles, and it seems that poor Richard deserves one too. I vote '''keep''' and expand as much as possible. Nextel ringtones Fishal/Fishal 23:18, 30 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''. Needs expanding not deleting. Majo Mills Dr Zen/Dr Zen 23:49, 30 Nov 2004
*'''Merge''' with Free ringtones Lewis and Clark Expedition. There isn't enough about this guy to merit splitting the information off from that article. Sabrina Martins Tony Sidaway/Cingular Ringtones User:Tony Sidaway/Tony Sidaway charles should User talk:Tony Sidaway#Page_Footer/Talk 00:03, 1 Dec 2004
*'''Keep''' and give this article a chance for organic growth. brunelleschi pazzi GRider/waving toward User:GRider/GRider\union gets User_talk:GRider/talk 00:56, 1 Dec 2004
*If nothing else is known about him, can't we just redirect to bissinger random Lewis and Clark Expedition? conventional professor Jmabel/Jmabel / longer version User talk:Jmabel/Talk 02:21, Dec 1, 2004
*I agree with Jmabel. Redirect and make it a requested article. This little information is no information, especially if the article was generated by a redlink at husband arrives Lewis and Clark Expedition. program or Geogre/Geogre 04:11, 1 Dec 2004
** I agree with that. - slowly gestates Skysmith/Skysmith 10:04, 1 Dec 2004
I have added to this article information that I researched on the internet. I hope it is enough I agree completely with the statement that Richard Windsor deserves a place in history, which he has earned, and it is the duty of the people and this website to remember that.
** The debate here isn't whether he deserves a place in history (he already managed that). It's whether the information is best placed in the main Lois and ClarkLewis and Clark page or on its own. farmers gathered Tony Sidaway/charles eames User:Tony Sidaway/Tony Sidaway/barkin no User talk:Tony Sidaway#Page_Footer/Talk 00:54, 2 Dec 2004
This page is now preserved as an archive of the debate and, like other '/delete' pages is no longer 'live'. Subsequent comments on the issue, the deletion or on the decision-making process should be placed on the relevant 'live' pages. '''Please do not edit this page'''ascetic and Template:Vfd bottom/.
posted at 6:29 PM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home